Lights, Digicam, Motion: Florida Courtroom Guidelines Insured Can Report Appraisal Inspection – Actual Property and Development


United States:

Lights, camera, action: Florida court rulings that insured people can record a valuation inspection

July 21, 2021

Butler Weihmüller Katz Craig LLP

To print this article, all you need to do is register or log in to

On July 7, 2021, the Florida Fourth District Court of Appeals ruled that an insured could electronically capture an insurer’s appraiser during an inspection of the insured’s property. The case is Silversmith versus State Farm Ins. Co., 2021 WL 2910240, 4D20-2685 (4th DCA July 7, 2021).

The case occurred after an insured person filed a property insurance claim. The insurer applied for the damage to be examined in accordance with the assessment rule of the insurance policy. The insured brought an action to determine that he had the right to electronically record the insurer’s appraiser when inspecting their property. The insured requested a summary judgment. The court dismissed the motion, ruling that Florida privacy laws prohibited eavesdropping on certain oral conversations and that all participants involved must consent to an electronic recording of the assessment.

The appellate court disagreed, ruling that privacy concerns do not apply when the insurer’s appraiser is on the insured’s property because the appraiser does not have legitimate reliance on privacy when assessing the insured’s property. Thus, Florida law does not prevent the insured from electronically recording the appraiser. In addition, the appeals court found that nothing in the insurance policy prohibited inclusion.

The appellate report does not address whether an insurer could include wording in an insurance policy that would prevent an insured person from electronically recording an appraisal review.

The content of this article is intended to provide general guidance on the subject. Expert advice should be sought regarding your specific circumstances.

POPULAR ARTICLES ON: United States Real Estate and Construction